11 March 2002

 News This Issue:

 QUOTE OF THE WEEK:

 
 

A MYSTERIOUS KIDNAPPING
There has been a great deal of confusion over events surrounding the kidnapping of Lizardo Sosa, the governor of the central bank of Guatemala. On Monday 25 February, Sosa was enjoying his customary morning jog when he was grabbed by a gang of masked villains. But it is still unclear who exactly his kidnappers were, or what they wanted. Contradictory and obfuscatory official information - including assertions that in fact Sosa was only off sick - gave conspiracy theorists a first-rate opportunity to sow doubt in people's minds. Was there a cover up? Did the kidnappers have political motivations? Perhaps it was an act of vengeance for actions Sosa has recently taken? Or was the incident designed to lay their hands on market-sensitive information? It might just have been an attempt to destabilise the current administration.

Who knows? Mr Sosa certainly doesn't. He has spoken out to the press, but maintains an air of bafflement which is in keeping with the whole episode: "About the motive of the action, I wouldn't be so bold to say...I haven't received death threats at the bank. There have been measures taken that have affected certain people, but they have been measures approved by the monetary board according to law. I don't know whether to say if it was politically motivated or a common crime."

But puzzlingly, the abductors' demands were apparently quite modest: although they must have felt obliged to demand a nominal sum, Mr Sosa assures us that "it was much less than was mentioned in the media", although he did get some help from "friends from the private sector" to come up with the required amount. Equally fortunately for Sosa, they sound like fairly reasonable captors. Although they held him in a small, dark room they didn't ask him anything and he wasn't tortured or mistreated in any way. He said: "They gave me food...They gave me medicine that I always take...and they called me 'Mr Lizardo.'" So what was it all about?

 
 

SABIRIN TRIAL DRAGS ON
Sjahril Sabirin, the governor of Bank Indonesia, is on trial for charges of abuse of power, and is still awaiting the verdict which was due to be announced on March 6. He will have been dismayed to discover that the agony of suspense was to be prolonged since the announcement was adjourned for another week: the presiding judge was "not ready to make a decision" because he had a "headache and a cough".

Sabirin has the full support of the central bank; a spokesman tells me that all the staff "strongly believe our governor has done nothing wrong". The bank maintains that all along his case has been dominated by unsavoury political motives aimed at cramping the central bank's independence, originating in the wishes of the previous government to foist a rather more compliant leader onto the bank. You can find out more about the case on the bank's website: http://www.bi.go.id/bank_indonesia_english/special/gbicase/

 
[Top]
  BANK INDONESIA TOP BRASS TO GET THE AXE
In what is widely interpreted as yet another government assault on the bank's independence, after long delays the process of the amendment of Bank Indonesia Act was resumed earlier in February. Current proposals include the replacement of the board of governors (though not the governor himself) sizing it down to just five members. Thus senior deputy governor Anwar Nasution and deputy governor Miranda Goeltom, currently in charge of foreign exchange and monetary policy, could be jettisoned from the bank's payroll. This is clearly a grave threat to its future independence since it indicates the government's ability and willing to change or dismiss the board by amending the law again as and when it sees fit.
 
  DAGGERS DRAWN IN POLAND
Sparks have been flying in Poland as the central bank and parliament trade blows over the bank's recent decision to leave interest rates unchanged. Leszek Balcerowicz, the long-suffering governor of the bank, is getting rather bored with being criticised by ignorant politicians. Reacting to parliamentary sniping, Balcerowicz let fire a salvo of searing remarks in a recent radio interview: "When I hear attempts to put the blame for unemployment on monetary policy, the same monetary policy that has rescued the country from a financial crisis, I can only conclude that we're dealing not just with aggression, but with outright lies." His opinion of the government's economic strategy is scathing in the extreme: "Either we're dealing with a programme whose basic assumptions are absurd from the standpoint of economic theory and experience, or with a pure propaganda manoeuvre designed to lay the blame (on the central bank) if growth proves slower than planned." Balcerowicz has not been the only one to suffer: the deputy president of the central bank, Andrzej Bratkowski, was summoned to parliament to explain the cut in rates, only to be described as appearing "stoned" by one politician. His rejoinder was barbed: "I doubt that any member of this house could insult me."
 
[Top]
 

ECB SUCCESSION SAGA - CONTINUED…
Fresh developments in the ECB succession rumpus have brought to light that there is a hopeful in Belgium for the top job in the shape of the country's finance minister, Didier Reynders. He has been quoted as saying: "I have never said I would not be interested in the presidency of the ECB, but not (just as) a member of the board." But he clarified: "If France maintains Jean-Claude Trichet's candidacy for the presidency, we will support it. But it would not be normal for Belgium not to be represented on the board."

The Belgians are evidently eager to be a part of the decision-making process: they have formally proposed that Paul de Grauwe, the well known economist, should be considered a runner for the number two spot soon to be vacated by Noyer. This puts a spanner in the works for Greece, since central bank governor Lucas Papademos has recently been rumoured to be the frontrunner for the position. But the two have very different backgrounds. Papademos is a seasoned central banker, described by Rodrigo Rato, Spain's finance minister, as "a person of recognised standing". De Grauwe on the other hand is not practiced in the dark art, although he is a professor of economics and a member of the Belgian parliament.

So are we to assume that Papademos will win the day? Despite the competition, that seems to be what people are saying. This may come as a belated surprise to even Papademos himself. He has admitted that before he was initiated into the ways of central banking, he wasn't sure it would really be for him: "When I joined the central bank in 1985, I wasn't quite sure that central banking would become the central element in my career...Gradually, it became more obvious that I was attracted by the ability to be involved in formulating and implementing monetary policy." And he has had some success in fulfilling his desires. When not formulating monetary policy, he professes to enjoy listening to music, taking long walks in winter in the hills outside Athens and going swimming in summer.

He will have been helped by the unwillingness of others to participate in the competition. The Portuguese central bank governor, Vitor Constancio has withdrawn from the contest on account of his reluctance to deracinate: "I am not a candidate because I do not want to leave the country." He added that he was not aware of any other Portuguese contenders. His opposite number in Austria, Klaus Liebscher, has also displayed little enthusiasm for the post, citing "private reasons" for wanting to stay in Vienna, and it has since been announced that Austria will not put a candidate forward for the vice-presidency.

 
[Top]
 

NEXT UP AT THE BANK OF KOREA ?
The term of the current governor of the Bank of Korea, Chon Chol-hwan, is due to expire at the end of this month, on March 31. Several names have been put forward as suggestions for who might take his place, with Professor Chung Woon-chan of Seoul National University leading the ratings to succeed him. Others include Ryu Shi-yol, president of the Korean Federation of Banks, as well as the current governor Chon himself, and his deputy, Park Cheul.

According to the Korea Herald, the results of a recent survey showed that 44% were in favour of a civilian financial export taking charge of the central bank, while 28% preferred a candidate from the central bank itself. Oddly, only 60% of central bankers thought that a central banker should take the job.

Also, an overwhelming majority of 92% believed that the governor should remain in office for a full four-year term and that there should be no political interference, something of a problem in Korea. It is usually the case that a new president (the next elections are scheduled for December this year) replaces the central bank head regardless of whether or not the term of office has expired.

 
 

HAPPY BIRTHDAY !
A toast to Alan Greenspan who reached the venerable age of 76 on March 6, though he cannot boast to be the oldest central bank governor until Japan's Hayami steps down. But his seniority seems by no means to have dampened his zeal for the job: he continues to confound those sceptics who think he will not last out his term. There was renewed speculation that he might choose to announce his resignation on his birthday, as people thought he might want to "quit while he was ahead".

There is no shortage of suggestions as to who might replace him. Central bankers include Greenspan's own vice-chairman, Roger Ferguson and William McDonough, president of the New York Fed; others are former Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, former Stanford Professor John Taylor, who now heads the monetary division at the US Treasury, Lawrence Lindsey, chief economic adviser to the White House, and Professor Martin Feldstein, who served in the White House under Reagan.

 
[Top]
  Pakistan GOVERNOR IN GOOD HEALTH
I am pleased to learn that the governor of the State Bank of Pakistan, Dr. Ishrat Husain, has fully recovered from the heart attack he suffered at the beginning of February, and is now back on the job. He returned to work on February 21 after taking 14 days leave during which time his deputy governor, Mr Chughtai, acted as governor.
 
  BOTSWANA 'S EMINENT CENTRAL BANKER
The lady governor of the Bank of Botswana, Linah Mohohlo, was warmly congratulated by her staff for being nominated as "Central Bank Governor of the Year (2001) for Africa and the Middle East Region" by the The Banker magazine in February. Mohohlo expressed her gratitude to the staff of the bank and others "who have always extended unselfish support, thus enabling [me] to make a mark in central banking." Last year she was appointed by the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, as "Eminent Person" to serve in a panel established to oversee and supervise the evaluation of the "United Nations New Agenda for the Development of Africa in the 1990s" (UN-NADAF). http://bankofbotswana.bw/Govn's_award.htm
 
[Top]
  ANOTHER CENTRAL BANK?
Do we have another central bank on our hands? When I referred to the authority on the subject, the Morgan Stanley Central Bank Directory, I could not find the Trans-Dniester Republican Bank amongst its pages. Those in the bank itself would doubtless protest at its absence. According to its website, the bank "acts as the central bank of Trans-Dniester Moldavian Republic on the international scene." Furthermore, "the central bank serves criterion for the introduction of the state into the European economic and currency union." This is something that Moldovans would hotly dispute: they consider what they refer to on their national website rather damningly as the Transnistrian "republic" (note the inverted commas, small 'r') to be a part of Moldova. I would welcome feedback from anyone who has an opinion as to whether this institution can be considered a central bank. Here is a link to their website: http://www.cbpmr.net/eng/index.html
 
   

 QUOTE OF THE WEEK:

  In a meeting with Treasury Select Committee, Sir Edward George, the governor of the Bank of England, demonstrated commendable central bankerly solidarity with his US counterpart. Alan Greenspan was quoted by a committee member as saying that the US recession "was over". Asked whether he agreed, Sir Edward replied:
"I do agree with Alan Greenspan. What exactly did he say?"
   
 
How to Subscribe/Unsubscribe

To Subscribe or Unsubscribe go to http://www.centralbanking.co.uk/list.htm
Or send an e-mail to listserver@centralbanking.co.uk with the words "SUBSCRIBE NEWSMAKERS" in the body of the text.

To Unsubscribe put "UNSUBSCRIBE NEWSMAKERS" in the body of the text. Alternatively, send an email to ncourtis@centralbanking.co.uk with your request.
Disclaimer of Warranty

Central Banking Publications assumes no responsibility for errors or omissions in these materials.

THESE MATERIALS ARE PROVIDED "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR NON-INFRINGEMENT.

Central Banking Publications further does not warrant the accuracy or completeness of the information, text, graphics,links or other items contained within these materials. Central Banking Publications shall not be liable for any special, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages, including without limitation, lost revenues or lost profits, which may result from the use of these materials. The information on this server is subject to change without notice and does not represent a commitment on the part of Central Banking Publications in the future.